Engaging Your Board in Fundraising: Strategies That Work

Engaging Your Board in Fundraising

Your board is one of your nonprofit’s greatest assets, but too often, fundraising becomes the sole responsibility of staff. When your board is equipped, empowered, and engaged, they can become incredible champions for your mission, opening new doors to funding, partnerships, and visibility.

Here are five practical strategies to help activate your board without overwhelming them.


🔑 1. Personalize the Ask

What It Is: Tailor fundraising involvement to each board member’s strengths and comfort level.

How to Do It:

  • Offer a “menu” of fundraising options: host an event, share a social media campaign, invite colleagues to attend something fun like a Paint & Sip.
  • Consider their networks, interests, and availability when assigning tasks.

Why It Works: Flexibility leads to higher engagement. When board members feel empowered, not pressured, they’re more likely to participate meaningfully.


🎁 2. Encourage Micro-Events

What It Is: Support board members in hosting small, informal fundraisers in their homes or communities.

Ideas Include:

  • Holiday raffles
  • Backyard concerts
  • Trivia nights
  • Wine tastings

How to Support Them:

  • Provide an easy-to-follow toolkit with marketing templates and planning checklists.
  • Offer staff or volunteer support for logistics if needed.

Revenue Potential: $500–$3,000 per event, depending on size and structure.


📣 3. Leverage Their Networks

What It Is: Help board members bring your nonprofit into their personal and professional circles.

Action Steps:

  • Share pre-written social media captions and graphics.
  • Create email templates they can personalize and send.
  • Encourage them to introduce you to potential sponsors or invite friends to events.

Why It Works: Word-of-mouth and peer recommendations are powerful tools especially when they come from trusted community leaders.


🧠 4. Educate and Inspire

What It Is: Help your board understand the impact of fundraising and their role in it.

How to Do It:

  • Host a brief training or Q&A session on “Fundraising 101.”
  • Share success stories and clear data on how funds have made a difference.
  • Celebrate fundraising wins publicly to build momentum and confidence.

Result: Informed board members are more confident, motivated, and effective.


🛠️ 5. Provide Tools & Resources

What It Is: Make fundraising participation simple and accessible.

Helpful Tools Include:

  • Board fundraising toolkit (templates, event checklists, digital resources)
  • Peer-to-peer fundraising platforms like Classy, GiveButter, or GoFundMe
  • Sample email asks and thank-you notes

Bonus Tip: Assign a staff liaison to help board members execute ideas with ease.


💬 Final Thoughts: Make It a Conversation

Rather than assigning tasks, ask your board members:

  • What excites you most about this mission?
  • How would you like to help raise awareness or support?

The most successful board engagement strategies are collaborative. When fundraising feels like a shared mission, not a mandate, board members become your nonprofit’s most passionate advocates.

Check out our Board Handout!


📘 More Ways to Strengthen Your Funding Strategy

If you’re looking for additional ways to reduce reliance on a single revenue stream, check out our Guide to Diversifying Your Nonprofit Funding. It includes practical tools to help your organization increase financial resilience and plan for long-term success.


🎯 Want Fresh Fundraising Ideas to Share with Your Board?

Explore our companion article:
👉 Fundraising Events & Techniques That Work for Small Nonprofits

It’s full of scalable, budget-friendly fundraising ideas that your board members can help lead or promote.

Fundraising Events & Techniques That Work for Small Nonprofits

Fundraising Events & Techniques

When resources are tight, small nonprofits need creative, cost-effective fundraising strategies that offer high returns both in dollars and donor engagement. Whether you’re looking for a fresh idea or adapting an existing event, these proven techniques can help your organization raise more with less.


🎨 Art Auction with a Twist

What it is: Guests bid on artwork created live by local artists.
Why it works: Watching art come to life creates a deeper emotional connection to the cause and the creators.
Cost: $$ (venue, supplies, refreshments, marketing)
How to do it on Long Island:

  • Partner with local artists, art students, or schools
  • Use a community center, library, or donated gallery space
  • Ask local restaurants to sponsor refreshments or music
  • Promote through social media, chambers, and artist networks

📵 Digital Detox Challenge

What it is: Participants unplug from devices and raise money through pledges.
Why it works: Encourages mindfulness while reinforcing mission-aligned values like literacy, wellness, or family connection.
Cost: $ (mostly promotion)
Real-World Inspiration: Willow Tree’s “Unplug-A-Thon” encouraged families to go screen-free and read together, strengthening family bonds while supporting their cause.
How to do it on LI:

  • Encourage schools, churches, or libraries to join
  • Set pledge levels (e.g., $1 per hour unplugged)
  • Share reflections and photos to drive engagement

👕 Custom Merchandise Fundraising

What it is: Sell branded t-shirts, mugs, or totes using print-on-demand platforms no inventory required.
Cost: $ (design and promotion only)
Success Tip: A Custom Ink campaign sold 255 shirts in 26 days, raising $4,257.
How to do it on LI:

  • Create locally themed or cause-driven designs
  • Collaborate with artists for unique flair
  • Promote through social media, events, and newsletters

🎶 Benefit Concerts

What it is: Host a themed music event with sponsors and ticket sales.
Big Success: The Two Charities, One Goal concert raised $1.83 million with 1,100 guests and 112 sponsors. Check out the full Case Study here.
How to scale it down:

  • Use local bands and smaller venues
  • Incorporate raffles and refreshments
  • Use sponsorships to cover costs

🍷 Paint & Sip Events

What it is: A relaxed evening of painting and wine, led by a local artist.
Typical Costs & Revenue:

  • Tickets: $35–$50
  • Supplies & venue: ~$500
  • With 50 guests, raise ~$1,500
    How to do it on LI:
  • Collaborate with an art teacher or wine bar
  • Offer raffles or sell art created at the event

🎥 Outdoor Movie Night

What it is: A community event screening a family-friendly movie under the stars.
Why it works: Combines fun, fundraising, and community.
Revenue Streams:

  • Tickets ($10/person)
  • Concessions & raffles
  • Sponsorships
    How to do it on LI:
  • Use a park, school field, or donated outdoor space
  • Partner with local AV companies for equipment
  • Secure a movie license (Swank or Criterion Pictures)

🧍 Peer-to-Peer (P2P) Fundraising

What it is: Supporters raise funds by activating their own networks.
Why it works: Expands your reach and brings in new donors.
Popular P2P Formats:

  • 5K Walks/Runs
  • Dance-a-thons or Step Challenges
  • Viral Social Media Challenges
    Success Story: BrainUp’s 5K in Chicago drew 1,100 attendees and raised $271,000 with just 15 sponsors. Check out the full Case Study here.

🍽️ Restaurant Fundraiser Night

What it is: A local restaurant donates a portion of sales during a set night.
Why it works: Passive, low-effort, and community-focused.
Restaurant Contributions: Typically 10%–25% of sales
Examples:

  • Chili’s “Give Back Night”
  • Chipotle’s 25% donation model
    How to do it on LI:
  • Choose high-traffic nights
  • Promote heavily via email and flyers
  • Encourage takeout/delivery participation

💡 More Low-Cost Fundraising Ideas

These ideas require minimal resources but can deliver big results:

  1. Trivia Night at a local pub
  2. Bingo for a Cause with bonus rounds
  3. Cooking/Baking Classes (virtual or in-person)
  4. Community Yard Sale with donated goods
  5. Dog Wash Day with volunteers and a hose
  6. Board Game Night with snacks for sale
  7. Coin Drive with a public tracker
  8. Photo Sessions with local photographers
  9. Karaoke Night with “vote by donation”
  10. Seasonal Mini Markets (wreaths, pumpkins, etc.)

🧭 Final Thoughts

Small nonprofits can thrive by choosing fundraisers that align with their mission, engage their community, and make the most of available resources. Whether you host a movie night, launch a t-shirt campaign, or try a digital detox, the key is creativity, planning, and consistent follow-up.

🔗 Related Resources
Engaging Your Board in Fundraising: Read the Article »
Guide to Diversifying Your Nonprofit Funding:
https://nonprofitresourcehub.org/guide-to-diversifying-your-nonprofit-funding